How to Choose an Umbrella: A Complete Guide to Types and Materials
We independently test the products and technologies that we recommend.
1. Types of Umbrellas
Choosing the type of umbrella largely determines its convenience and longevity. The market offers two main options — the classic cane umbrella and the foldable umbrella. Each has its own strengths and weaknesses, and the right choice depends on the owner's lifestyle.
1.1 Cane Umbrella
A classic that has long been a symbol of reliability and elegance. Thanks to its solid construction, these umbrellas are sturdier than foldable ones, less prone to breaking, and better at withstanding wind. They are often chosen by business people and drivers, as a cane umbrella doesn't need folding and can easily be kept in a car.
1.2 Foldable Umbrella
Foldable models are most commonly seen in everyday life. They easily fit into a backpack or handbag and become indispensable companions in the city. However, compactness has its downside: the more sections an umbrella has, the greater the risk of breakage in strong winds. Therefore, it's worth choosing models with reinforced frames and windproof systems.
1.3 Which Umbrella Type to Choose?
It's not easy to say that one type is better than the other. If durability and wind protection are important to you, choose a cane umbrella. If you value compactness and mobility, a foldable umbrella is the perfect solution. Choose an umbrella based on your habits and usage conditions.
| Umbrella Type | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Cane Umbrella |
|
|
| Foldable Umbrella |
|
|
2. Mechanism and Construction
When selecting an umbrella, it's important to consider not only its type but also the opening mechanism. This affects usability, opening speed, and structure durability. There are three main types on the market: manual, semi-automatic, and automatic. Each option has its pros and cons, so it's worth exploring them further.
2.1 Manual Umbrella
The simplest and yet the most reliable option. All actions — opening and closing — are done manually. It's because of the absence of complex springs and buttons that these umbrellas last the longest and rarely break. Ideal for those who value durability and reliability, but are willing to sacrifice opening speed.
2.2 Semi-Automatic
A compromise option. To open the canopy, just press a button, but folding must be done manually. This is convenient if you often need to open an umbrella quickly, while maintaining relative mechanism simplicity. Reliability is higher than automatics but lower than manual ones.
2.3 Automatic Umbrella
The most convenient option: a single button press can both open and fold the canopy. However, this system has more moving parts, making it more susceptible to breakage, especially in budget models. Cheap automatics often break, so we recommend choosing models from reputable manufacturers.
2.4 Which Option to Choose?
If reliability and durability are a priority, it's better to choose a manual umbrella. For those looking for a compromise between sturdiness and comfort, a semi-automatic will suit. If speed and convenience are your top priority, an automatic umbrella will be the best solution, but it's essential to choose a quality model.
| Umbrella Construction | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Manual |
|
|
| Semi-Automatic |
|
|
| Automatic |
|
|
3. Spoke Materials
Spoke quality determines umbrella performance in bad weather. Lightweight alloys are easy to carry but less resilient under stress, while modern composites offer flexibility and strength. Let's delve into the most common materials and their differences:
- Aluminum – the lightest, most affordable option. Suitable for foldable umbrellas always on the go. Downside: low strength, spokes easily bend in strong winds.
- Steel – a sturdy material that retains shape even in high winds. Downsides: weight and tendency to rust.
- Fiberglass – a modern material often listed as fiberglass, when they're essentially the same. Made from fine glass fibers infused with polymer resin, mostly used alongside metal bases (near opening mechanisms). Fiberglass spokes are light, resistant to rust, and handle bending well, even returning to shape after high-pressure winds. It's thanks to these properties that fiberglass sees frequent use in wind-resistant umbrellas.
- Carbon Fiber – distinguishes light weight with high strength. Like fiberglass, usually found at spoke tips paired with metal bases. Used in premium umbrellas where durability and light weight are key. Carbon spokes are rarer due to high cost.
4. Number of Spokes
Number of spokes affects umbrella appearance and wind resistance. More spokes distribute weight evenly. Available in various spoke counts:
- Up to 6 spokes – most budget-friendly. Good as "spare" in a bag, but wind easily inverts its canopy.
- 7-8 spokes – standard for most quality models. Offers a strong and lightweight balance, handling regular rain and moderate winds well.
- 9–10 spokes – more reinforced models, better wind resistance, longer lifespan. Common in storm umbrellas.
- Over 10 spokes – premium umbrellas or classic canes. 12, 14, or 16 spokes enhance canopy strength and shape. Great for those prioritizing style and durability.
5. Frame Material
An umbrella's frame is not only the spokes but also the central tube. It keeps the entire structure steady and ensures rigidity. A tube made from weak materials can bend or break with strong winds. Let's go deeper into the materials used for umbrella frames and their pros and cons:
- Steel – the most common choice for durable umbrellas. Steel tubes endure heavy loads and provide wind resistance. Downsides: weight and potential rust if the umbrella is stored damp.
- Aluminum – lightweight and affordable. Great for foldable umbrellas, where compactness and minimal weight are key. However, aluminum poorly withstands bends, possibly bending under high pressure winds.
- Fiberglass – less common than in spokes but present in storm umbrellas. Offers high flexibility and rust resistance. Fiberglass tubes are lighter than steel but may crack under strong impacts.
- Carbon Fiber – a lightweight, premium material. Carbon tubes barely bend and resist rust, being significantly lighter than steel. Main disadvantage is its high cost, hence carbon fiber sees rare use only in expensive models.
6. Canopy Material
Canopy fabric defines umbrella practicality, affecting water resistance, durability, appearance, and weight. Let's explore popular options:
- Polyester – most common in budget models. Repels water well, dries fast, and affordable. However, with heavy use, fabric may lose shape, and bright colors can fade in the sun.
- Nylon – lightweight, stretchy, expands when wet. Nylon umbrellas can soak in heavy rain and quickly lose shape. Less common now than polyester.
- Pongee – a modern fabric with a coat that mimics high-quality textile. Has excellent water resistance, resists dirt, and holds its look over time. Pongee is found in budget and mid-to-premium umbrellas—difference lies in treatment quality and density.
- Jacquard and Satin – premium fabrics with high density and stylish texture. These umbrellas are elegant, lasting longer than average. Jacquard is woven for complexity, and satin, with a slight sheen, comes at a higher price
7. Canopy Size
When choosing an umbrella, many focus on color and design, but size matters too. Sizes determine how well it protects from rain and its portability. Striking a balance between practicality and comfort is vital: a large umbrella offers better rain coverage but occupies more space; a compact one is handy for daily use yet may not hold up in strong winds. Therefore, when selecting, consider diameter and canopy depth — key to effectiveness and ease of use.
7.1 Canopy Diameter
- Small (up to 100 cm) — suitable for one person, easily fits in a bag.
- Medium (100–120 cm) — a versatile choice for everyday use.
- Large (120 cm and above) — often accommodates two, offers great coverage but may be heavy.
7.2 Canopy Depth
A deeper canopy provides better rain and side wind protection. Especially relevant in windy regions or cities where air currents intensify between buildings.
8. Handle and Usability
The importance of a handle is often underestimated, though it heavily impacts umbrella usability. A poor or uncomfortable handle can chafe on the hand, slip during rain, or quickly wear out. When choosing, consider not only material but also shape.
8.1 Handle Material
- Plastic — the most common choice. Lightweight and vibrant, but cheap models can slip in the hand and crack over time.
- Wood — a classic and stylish option. Wooden handles feel good to touch yet can be damaged by moisture.
- Rubber or Rubber Coated Inserts — offer reliable grip even in wet hands.
- Eco-leather or Leather — sophisticated look, feels good to hold, but budget models' materials can quickly peel.
8.2 Handle Shape
- Straight — a minimalist option, convenient for storage in a bag or backpack.
- Curved (Hook) — classic, easy to hang on a wrist or hook.
- Ergonomic — fits the palm shape, reduces fatigue when carried for long.
9. Additional Features
Modern umbrellas have evolved beyond mere weather protection. Manufacturers integrate new technologies to enhance convenience and safety. Additional features may seem secondary but greatly affect usability. Here are the most popular enhancements:
- Umbrellas with UV Protection – these models feature a special canopy coating that blocks 95-99% UV rays. They protect not only from rain but also from intense sunlight, shielding skin and clothes from fading. Especially relevant in summer and for travelers.
-
Storm Umbrellas
– designed to withstand strong winds and bad weather. Reinforced frames with flexible spokes manage heavy loads, quickly returning the umbrella to its original shape after inversion.
-
Reverse Folding Umbrellas
– the canopy folds inside, trapping water so it doesn’t wet clothes. This system is handy for drivers – car seats stay dry when getting in, also useful for those frequently entering places with a wet umbrella.
- Pattern-Revealing Umbrellas – appear solid when dry, revealing patterns or designs in the rain. Achieved via special water-repellent paint. This umbrella stands out, adding brightness on gloomy days.
-
Reflective Band Umbrellas – glow-in-the-dark trim along the canopy edge or fabric sections. Makes the user more visible to drivers at night, crucial on unlit crossings. These umbrellas combine practicality with safety emphasis.
-
Flashlight Handle Umbrellas – a useful choice for those often walking in the evening or at night. Built-in LED-light helps illuminate paths, making the user visible to drivers, ensuring confidence on dim paths. This merges rain protection with added safety.
10. Common Mistakes When Choosing an Umbrella
We've covered key parameters to consider when buying an umbrella. However, people still make common errors. Here are the most frequent ones:
- Choosing based solely on appearance. A beautiful umbrella doesn't guarantee reliability. Stylish models with thin aluminum spokes and bright canopies may break in their first strong wind gusts. Aesthetic is important, but should come alongside robust build.
- Skimping on mechanism quality. The most frequent complaint about cheap umbrellas is a broken automatic mechanism. A budget model with a flimsy mechanism means button or spring failures soon. Invest initially in a trusted brand to avoid frequent replacements after heavy rain.
- Too light or heavy an umbrella. Mini umbrellas weighing up to 300 grams are convenient but seldom withstand strong winds. Conversely, heavy steel models tire users quickly. An umbrella with a fiberglass frame is a balanced choice — sturdy yet lightweight.
- Overlooking additional features. Many shoppers ignore options like windproofing, UV protection, or reflective bands. Yet these significantly enhance umbrella comfort and safety.
11. FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)
If you still have questions after all this information — that's normal. Here are the most common queries with simple answers:
11.1 Which umbrella is best against wind?
Wind-resistant models with strengthened, flexible fiberglass spokes perform best in wind.
11.2 What’s more reliable — automatic or manual?
A manual umbrella is more reliable since it has fewer moving parts that can fail. But if swift opening is crucial, choose a quality automatic from a reputable brand.
11.3 Is it okay to wash an umbrella in a washing machine?
Washing an umbrella in a machine is inadvisable — it destroys the water-repellent coating, deforms the fabric, and may damage the frame. Moving parts risk jamming or breaking from drum impacts. For care, rinse the canopy with warm soapy water and dry the umbrella fully opened.
11.4 What canopy material lasts longer?
Pongee or satin are best for longevity: they fade less, resist moisture, and hold their shape better than polyester and nylon.
11.5 What umbrella brands are considered the best?
Among popular and reliable brands are:
- Fulton (United Kingdom) — European-favored umbrellas with robust constructions and stylish designs.
- Knirps (Germany) — foldable umbrella pioneers renowned for quality.
- Perletti (Italy) — stylish umbrellas in the mid-price range.
- Zest (Poland) — popular in Eastern Europe, offering good price-to-quality ratios.
12. Conclusion
Choosing an umbrella isn't just about aesthetics but a practical decision affecting your comfort in wet weather. Frame reliability, canopy fabric quality, opening mechanism ease, and extra features like wind or UV protection — all play a role.
Approach selection mindfully: consider where and how you often use an umbrella, under what conditions, and how important compactness, style, or weather resistance is to you. Such an approach will help find the model that will last long without failing in crucial moments.
